Things are going well, though. I'm up to 7-mile long runs though the new foot issues are threatening to slow me back down.
So tonight I ordered MORE new shoes! Salomon was recommended to me as a good brand, and reading the reviews on Amazon, this seems to be fairly universal opinion. The Salomon XR Missions were on sale (for some colors -- not for the gorgeous purple, sadly) so I ordered a bright yellow pair. We'll see if those help.
I think the way I run has shifted so it isn't so much the shoes as my post-injury feet and legs still working through to find the new normal. The Saucony's have done a great job and my once-broken toe doesn't even bother me anymore at all. The new annoyance is not even the same foot/leg which tells me it probably is a gait issue and that perhaps the Saucony's -- while helping overall and helping my weaker foot have caused me to run differently to the point where now my other leg is protesting and I need to figure out how to adjust back so both legs are happy.
Running is hard, y'all.